When questioned later, the author correctly observes that the proof contains all the key facts needed to actually prove the result. Legitimate sound generation of new sentences from old. Henning school of mathematical sciences university of kwazulunatal. Copy the statement of the theorem to be proved on your paper. The argument may use other previously established statements, such as theorems. In our earlier mathematical lives we called them counting numbers.
Conjunction introduction sometimes called conjunction. Detailed descriptions of direct and indirect methods of proof are given. In this introductory chapter we explain some methods of mathematical proof. Assume p, and then use the rules of inference, axioms, defi nitions, and logical equivalences to prove q. However, mathematicians tend to have extraordinarily high standards for what convincing means. This view fails to explain why it is very often the case that a new proof of a theorem is deemed important. If one number divides a second and the second number divides a third, then the first number divides the third. A complete chapter is dedicated to the different methods of proof such as forward direct proofs, proof by contrapositive, proof by contradiction, mathematical induction, and existence proofs. What i wanted from the text was to somehow incorporate the additional nuances that make ebooks slightly better than paper. The disadvantage of a nonconstructive proof is that it may. This lecture now we have learnt the basics in logic. Let w be a collection of subspaces of v with 2ifor some index i. A logical rule of inference is a method that depends on logic alone for deriving a new statement from a set of.
Premise 3 tells us that there are at least two cubes. A theorem is a mathematical statement that is true and can be and has been verified as true. Since the mathematical methods for achieving this depend a great deal on the type of. In doing so, our examples to illustrate the techniques should not be very complicated. Nonetheless, this skill is well within the reach of the willing student. Methods of proving a proof of the proposition of the form x px is called an existence proof sometimes, we can find an element s, called a witness, such that ps is true this type of existence proof is constructive sometimes, we may have nonconstructive existence proof, where we. Essentially, if you can show that a statement can not be false, then it must be true. The backbone of any good proof is a complete, watertight argument. Introduction to proof in analysis 2020 edition steve halperin with contributions from elizabeth hughes cc. To help systematize their approaches to theoremproving, we have prepared this monograph on methods of proof. Math isnt a court of law, so a preponderance of the evidence or beyond any reasonable doubt isnt good enough. Methods of proving a proof of the proposition of the form x px is called an existence proof sometimes, we can find an element s, called a witness, such that ps is true this type of existence proof is constructive sometimes, we may have nonconstructive existence proof, where we do not find the witness 20. Form a truth table in which the premises are columns, and the conclusion is the last column. A vacuous proof of an implication happens when the hypothesis of the implication is always false.
A mathematical proof is an argument which convinces other people that something is true. Methods of proof we will survey the basic proof methods. Theorems, corollaries, lemmas, and methods of proof. This conjecture has been verified for even numbers up to \1018\ as of the time of this writing. The literature refers to both methods as indirect methods of proof. You will learn andapply the methods of thought that mathematicians use to. Proof by contradiction versus proof by contraposition this part of the paper explores the differences and similarities that exist between proof by contraposition and proof by contradiction. Clearly mark the beginning of your proof with the word proof. Already in his famous \mathematical problems of 1900 hilbert, 1900 he raised, as the second. Today and tomorrow we will look at the following methods of proof.
Theorems, corollaries, lemmas, and methods of proof rossi. Birzeit university, palestine, 2016, 2 watch this lecture and download the slides acknowledgement. Vacuous proof trivial proof direct proof indirect proof proof by contradiction proof by cases. The theory of numbers provides an excellent source. A nonconstructive proof of existence involves showing either a that the existence of a value of x that makes qx true is guaranteed by an axiom or a previously proved theorem or b that the assumption that there is no such x leads to a contradiction. For each of the following statements, determine which of the following methods of proof is most appropriate, and then prove the statement. An introduction to logic and proof techniques michael a. In doing so, we also trace the shift over the past few decades from proofs based on combinatorial arguments, seen in what is known as the moment method, to. Universal elimination this rule is sometimes called universal instantiation. An existence statement asserts that objects with a given property exist. A formal proof is a derivation of a theorem that consists of a finite sequence of wellformed formulas.
We are going to apply the logical rules in proving mathematical theorems. Proof techniques jessica su november 12, 2016 1 proof techniques here we will learn to prove universal mathematical statements, like \the square of any odd number is odd. I argue that at least some of these criteria depend on the methods of inference the proofs employ, and that standard models of formal deduction are not well. I full details in the pdf posted under \admin documents. Direct proof contrapositive proof by contradiction proof by cases 3. Proof theory was created early in the 20th century by david hilbert to prove the consistency of the ordinary methods of reasoning used in mathematics in arithmetic number theory, analysis and set theory. This proof method is based on the law of the excluded middle. A proof of a theorem is a written verification that shows that the theorem is definitely and unequivocally true. Math 299 methods of proof solutions for each of the following statements, determine which of the following methods of proof is most appropriate, and then prove the statement. This document models those four different approaches by proving the same proposition four times over using each fundamental method.
The author writes down every theorem or result known to mankind and then adds a few more just for good measure. Proofs and mathematical reasoning university of birmingham. Premise 1 tells us that every cube is left of something, so we can infer that if a is a cube, then there is something that a is to the left of. When proving a conditional, one can prove the contrapositive statement instead of the original this is called a contrapositive proof. Mathematical proofmethods of proofproof by contradiction. Understanding this, we now proceed to summarize some methods of proof.
However, in the real world such logically valid arguments can get. Discussion the rst two methods of proof, the \trivial proof and the \vacuous proof are certainly the easiest when they work. The hypothesis is false, therefore the statement is vacuously true even though the conclusion is also false. Achieving full security through selective techniques allison lewko. Methods of proof direct, contradiction, conditional, contraposition. Most mathematical theorems are conditional or biconditional statements. They are argument by contradiction, the principle of mathematical induction, the pigeonhole principle, the use of an ordering on a set, and the principle of invariance. A mathematics proof establishes the validity of a mathematics statement. For example, consider the goldbach conjecture which states that every even number greater than 2 is the sum of two primes. Mathematical method and proof carnegie mellon university data. For example, in the index, i would have liked hyperlinks back to the page where the term was defined. An indirect proof uses rules of inference on the negation of the conclusion and on some of the premises to derive the negation of a premise.
A positive integer, such as 7, that cannot be written as a product of two smaller positive integers is called prime. Logical models illustrate the essence of specific types of indirect proofs. Think of a proof as a way to communicate a convincing argument for the truth of a mathematical statement. In practice, you assume that the statement you are trying to prove is false and then show that this leads to a contradiction any contradiction. Mathematical method and proof carnegie mellon university. Statements are assertions that can be broadly classified under two types.
On a traditional view, the primary role of a mathematical proof is to warrant the truth of the resulting theorem. Today we will look at the following methods of proof. Thenp is an integer since it is a product of integers. In addition, the author has supplied many clear and detailed algorithms that outline these proofs. Proof methods proof methods divide into roughly two kinds. Methods of proof ross mathematics program 2016 every summer, new rstyear students experience the frustrations that inevitably accompany their inability to justify their beliefs. Jun 29, 2006 theorems, corollaries, lemmas, and methods of proof uniquely introduces scratch work as an indispensable part of the proof process, encouraging students to use scratch work and creative thinking as the first steps in their attempt to prove a theorem. Catalog description math 248 methods of proof in mathematics 4 units prerequisite. Sometimes new methods are introduced in the course of a proof.
Its easy enough to show that this is true in speci c cases for example, 3 2 9, which is an odd number, and 5 25, which is another odd number. Theorems, corollaries, lemmas, and methods of proof uniquely introduces scratch work as an indispensable part of the proof process, encouraging students to use scratch work and creative thinking as the first steps in their attempt to prove a theorem. To prove that 3 is a subspace, it su ces to show closure under addition and scalar multiplication. Introduction to mathematical arguments background handout for courses requiring proofs by michael hutchings a mathematical proof is an argument which convinces other people that something is true. Divisibility two useful properties of divisibility are one of the most useful properties of divisibility is that it is transitive. Methods of proofs recall we discussed the following methods of proofs. Theoretically, a proof of a mathematical statement is no different than a logically valid argument starting with some premises and ending with the statement. We want to use di erent methods to prove general theorems so that we can apply them. Theorems, corollaries, lemmas, and methods of proof wiley. A rule of inference is a logical rule that is used to deduce one statement from others. Oct 28, 2014 detailed descriptions of direct and indirect methods of proof are given.
Over the years, the following rules of style have become fairly standard for writing the final versions of proofs. This document models those four di erent approaches by proving the same proposition four times over using each fundamental method. A mathematical proof is an inferential argument for a mathematical statement, showing that the stated assumptions logically guarantee the conclusion. Assume for the sake of contradiction that s is nonempty, so by the wellordering principle it has a least element l. Lastly, even in nonconstructive company, using the method in the first row of the table above is considered bad form that is, proving something by pseudoconstructive proof, since the proofbycontradiction part of it is nothing more than excess baggage. The reason is that the starting point and what is to be shown in a proof depend only on the linguistic form of the statement to be proved, not on the content of the statement. Here we will use the method of existential instantiation.